Meeting Cousin Rhonda for the first time in Silver Spring,
Maryland
On May 4,
2015, my cousin Orien Reid Nix sent me an inquiry e-mail. An
adoptee, Rhonda Roorda, contacted her because she is searching for her biological parents. Born in
Rochester, NY, the award-winning author of In Their Voices: Black Americans on
Transracial Adoption,
and also a consultant for the NBC TV series “This Is Us,” had taken two
autosomal DNA tests (FTDNA & AncestryDNA). Rhonda also uploaded her raw data
file to GEDmatch.com. Cousin Orien and Rhonda share 44 cM of identical DNA on
chromosome 3, with an additional 21 cM on the X chromosome. That amount
suggests the third cousin range. Cousin Orien asked me if it is possible if
Rhonda is related via our Danner-Bobo line. As second cousins, my mother and
Cousin Orien are both the great-granddaughters of Edward Danner Sr. (1832-1876)
and Louisa Bobo Danner (1842-1921) of Panola County (Como), Mississippi. Utilizing
the chromosome browser in GEDmatch, I soon realized three key things:
(1) Rhonda
also shares 17 cM with my mother’s brother on chromosome 15 and 18 cM on the X
chromosome, which overlaps with the 21 cM she shares with Cousin Orien on the
X.
(2) Rhonda
also shares 20 cM on the X with my mother in the same spot. These overlapping
segments, where everyone is matching each other on the same chromosome spot,
mean that they all inherited that identical DNA from a common ancestor.
(3) Rhonda
is also sharing 9 to 19 cM of identical DNA with four other descendants of
Edward and Louisa Danner.
Therefore,
the answer to Cousin Orien’s question was a resounding YES. Rhonda is our cousin via Edward and/or Louisa Danner. But how?
I also noticed that they all are sharing DNA with three people with the last
name PORTER. For privacy purposes, I
will call them Cousins A, B, and C. Those matches would prove to be very
conducive to honing in on the family connection and some of Cousin Rhonda’s
ancestry.
Months
later, a new AncestryDNA match (Cousin D) appeared among my mother’s DNA
matches. She shares 63 cM over 2 segments with my mother, and the “Shared
Matches” include six other descendants of Edward & Louisa Danner who took
the AncestryDNA test. Luckily, Cousin D attached a public family tree to her
profile. I didn’t see any common ancestors, but she had PORTERs in her family
tree. I soon discovered that she, as well as Cousins A, B, and C, all descend
from a couple named Albert Porter and Fillis Whitlock Porter via two of their
12 children. Cousin Rhonda is also sharing significant DNA with Cousins A, B,
C, and D, from 34 to 134 cM. Two other Porter descendants, Cousins E and F,
were also sharing weighty amounts of DNA with us, particularly Rhonda. See
chart below.
DNA Sharing Between Rhonda and Porter Descendants (Cousins A, B, C, D, E, and F)
This
analysis revealed that Cousin Rhonda is a descendant of Albert & Fillis
Porter, and one of them was closely-related to Edward or Louisa Danner. The
major commonality between the two couples is location. Grandma Louisa
“Lue” was enslaved by Dr. William Bobo, who transported her, her mother
Clarissa Bobo, and her numerous siblings to Panola County, Mississippi in 1858
from Union County, South Carolina.
On a trip back to South Carolina in 1859, Dr. Bobo purchased Grandpa Edward
from the Thomas Danner Jr. estate of Union County and brought him back to Mississippi.
According to his Civil War pension file, he had been born on the Danner farm,
which is why he kept the Danner surname. He never saw his family back in South Carolina
again. Edward and Louisa subsequently married in 1860.
Albert
& Fillis Porter were found in the 1870 and 1880 censuses, residing in Union
County! Albert was born around 1838 in South Carolina, and Fillis was born
around 1840, also in South Carolina. After 1880, they and their children later
migrated into Spartanburg County, near Wellford, where their family tree grew
by leaps and bounds. They became members of the Upper Shady Grove Baptist
Church (aka New Shady Grove Baptist Church) near Wellford.
Cousin
Rhonda and the Porters are not sharing DNA with family members related via
Grandma Louisa, who was fathered by a white man named Elijah Wilbourn Jr., according to oral history (DNA-proven). Therefore, the connection strongly appears to be via Grandpa
Edward. When the Danners sold Edward to Dr. Bobo, they also sold most of their 20+
slaves to raise funds for their pending move to Grant County, Arkansas. Thomas’
widow, Nancy Bates Danner, and their sons only kept a woman named Harriet
Danner, possibly Edward’s sister, and her seven children and took them to
Arkansas in 1859. Edward’s parents and siblings were sold to other slave-owners,
but I haven’t been able to uncover the names and whereabouts of Edward’s displaced
family members and who may have purchased them. This has been a longtime
mystery.
However,
these DNA findings with Cousin Rhonda and the Porters are leading me to believe
that Albert may have been Edward's brother, due to the amount of DNA my family
is sharing with them. So I started digging to try to prove or disprove it.
Here’s what I found.
Research Finding #1
In the online
Freedmen's Bureau records, now accessible at discoverfreedmen.org, I found an 1865 labor contract for
Albert & Phillis (Fillis) Porter, being contracted for their labor in Union
County, S.C. by M.S. Porter. These contracts “consist of agreements between
freedmen laborers and planters stating terms of employment, such as pay,
clothing, and medical care due the freedman; the part of the crop to be
retained by him; and whether a plot for growing subsistence crops was to be
provided.” (Source)
M.S. Porter was likely the last slave-owner who entered Albert and Fillis into
a labor contract shortly after enslaved people were emancipated.
1865 Freedmen’s Bureau Labor Contract – M.S. Porter &
Albert and Phillis (Read full contract here)
"South Carolina,
Freedmen's Bureau Field Office Records, 1865-1872," images, FamilySearch
(https://familysearch.org : 21 May 2014), Union district, Roll 105, Labor
contracts, series II, A-S, 1866
Research Finding #2
Per the
censuses, M.S. Porter was Marion Sandford Porter. He was only 21 years old in
1860 and was reported as being a planter. I checked the 1860 slave schedule,
and M.S. Porter (spelled Poter in the census) owned five slaves:
(1)
21-year-old black male
(2) 18-year-old mulatto female
(3) 10-year-old mulatto female
(4) 3-year-old mulatto male
(5) 1-year-old mulatto male
The
21-year-old black male fits the profile of Albert Porter. Perhaps, the 18-year-old
mulatto female may be Fillis? She was noted as being “mulatto” in the later censuses.
Research Finding #3
Fillis
died in 1921 in Spartanburg County. Luckily, her death certificate was found on
ancestry.com. Her father’s name was simply written as "Stark." Her
mother’s name was reported as being Mary Whitlock. Since she is reported as
being mulatto in the censuses, I wondered if her father may have been white,
keeping in mind that the census-taker’s mulatto notation was likely based on
appearance. But who was “Stark”? I immediately found my answer. It appears that
he was a white man named Stark Whitlock, born in 1818. His father was Bennett
Whitlock (1790-1859), whose 1859 estate record included a slave inventory.
Among the enslaved were a woman named Phillis and her oldest son, Dennis. In my
extensive research of Grandma Louisa’s family, I haven’t found any ties to the Whitlocks.
Interestingly, Cousin Rhonda shares sizeable amounts of DNA with numerous white
Whitlock descendants.
Research Finding #4
Marion
Sandford Porter's father was Hancock Porter, who died in 1852 in Union County.
Per the 1850 slave schedule, Hancock owned 12 slaves. His estate record
revealed that he did not own an enslaved male named Albert. Therefore, young Marion
appeared to have acquired Albert from somebody before 1860. Cousin C mentioned
that the oral history in the Porter family relays that Albert had been sold to
the Porter family and had been separated from own his family. Another
descendant, Marvin Porter, also shared with me that their oral history also
sadly claims that Albert was used to breed children during slavery. This history
was written in a 1987 article in the Philadelphia
Inquirer about the Porter family.
1987 Philadelphia
Inquirer Article
(Shared by Rhonda Roorda)
McCabe, Barbara. “Bus Driver Discover Road to Relatives.” The Philadelphia Inquirer [Philadelphia, PA] 9 July 1987: Page 30-M. Print.
McCabe, Barbara. “Bus Driver Discover Road to Relatives.” The Philadelphia Inquirer [Philadelphia, PA] 9 July 1987: Page 30-M. Print.
The
Porter Family’s oral history is matching up with the documented history about Grandpa
Edward Danner – the sad saga of enslaved families being permanently separated.
I am theorizing, with a high level of certainty, that Albert and Edward were
brothers who got sold and took different surnames. This was not uncommon. I
have no doubt that future DNA testing (and/or more genealogical research) will
help to solve this case. Stay tuned.
Cousin
Rhonda was recently invited down to Spartanburg, South Carolina to meet some of
the descendants of Albert & Fillis Porter, who have held a number of family
reunions and who garner a great pride in their family history. The resemblances
to Rhonda were quite noticeable. She shared, “It was a real blessing to be in
Spartanburg this past weekend and have the opportunity to meet some of these
amazing relatives. The fact that family members arranged a welcome gathering
for me was quite humbling and beautiful. The elders were so happy that they
could meet me, as I was them. It was a great trip.” Incredibly, her DNA match
to my Danner family led to a wonderful discovery – the Danners and Porters are blood
kinfolks. Our family histories added a special meaning to our biological
connection. However, the best outcome will be when Cousin Rhonda uncovers the
identity of one or both of her biological parents. That day will come.